Hello, dear readers. It is I, your in-house dreamcast expert, coming back with another incredible cast list for another theoretical masterpiece.
The Silmarillion, J.R.R. Tolkien's book about the prehistory before The Lord of the Rings, is a high fantasy treasure about the early days of Middle-earth. Unlike straightforward novels like The Hobbit, The Silmarillion is a collection of mythopoeic stories stretching from the creation of the universe (Eä) to the brith of the elves to the breaking of the world and beyond. It's a compilation of tales about the struggles of gods, elves, men, and dwarves against the fallen god Melkor, who later becomes Morgoth. The bulk of the book is set during the First Age, when the Elves battled Morgoth for possession of the Silmarils, precious jewels that held the light of creation. These stories are filled with tragedy, heroism, love, and betrayal, and we would love to see them onscreen.
Though nothing of the sort has been announced, a live-action adaptation of The Silmarillion would be freaking epic. It'd be an opportunity to bring to life some of the most majestic and awe-inspiring tales of fantasy ever written. The visual potential alone is staggering; we could see the shimmering lights of Valinor, the magical Two Trees, the tragic beauty of Gondolin and the climactic War of Wrath. An adaptation could explore themes like the nature of evil, the corruption of power, and the cost of pride and ambition. Characters like Fëanor, Lúthien, Beren, and Turin Turambar are crying out for the right actor to play them.
With all of that in mind, let's take a look at a handful of actors who could bring some of the most legendary characters from The Silmarillion to life, and do them justice.
1) Lúthien Tinúviel - Lily Collins
Lily Collins would be my ideal choice to play Lúthien Tinúviel, the elven princess who falls in love with a human man, creating a bloodline passed down through the generations all the way to the time of The Lord of the Rings. Collins isn't perfect for the part just because of her near fairytale-like beauty. Think back to her role in Mirror Mirror; she was the epitome of a fairytale character of charm and grace. Lúthien is an elf known for her breathtaking beauty and fiery spirit. Collins has this magical ability to combine innocence with spicy, something she showcased brilliantly as Snow White. She danced and fought with elegance, radiating a presence that was both enchanting and formidable. This is Lúthien to a tee: a character who's as much about ethereal beauty as she is about inner strength and courage.
In The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones, she played Clary, a young woman who discovers her own hidden powers and goes out into the world full of unseen dangers. Just like Lúthien -- who goes on a journey with Beren to steal a sacred Silmaril from the crown of the dark lord Morgoth -- Clary is thrust into impossiblel circumstances and rises to the challenge with a resilience that’s both relatable and inspiring. Much like Clary, Lúthien isn't just about looking the part; she's about embodying the spirit of someone who faces darkness with light. Collins would absolutely do justice to her journey.
We have many more characters and actors to match up. Click on:
2) Fëanor - Cillian Murphy
All I should have to do to justify Cillian Murphy having this role is to point to his performance as Julius Robert Oppenheimer in Christopher Nolan's 2023 epic, Oppenheimer. But for those who haven't watched Murphy's best work, I'll get into a bit more detail.
Murphy, with those piercing blue eyes and flair for playing intense, brooding characters, is a match made in cinematic heaven for the role of Fëanor, the most passionate and talented of the Elven craftsmen The Silmarillion; he's responsible for making the three Silmarils, jewels so spectaularly beautiful they start a centuries-long war between Morgoth and the elves. As Thomas Shelby in Peaky Blinders, Murphy played a complex, driven man, a leader who was both loved and feared. Now picture that same intensity, that same fire in his eyes, but in Tolkien's Middle-earth.
Fëanor is a character creates the Silmarils out of pure love and artistic genius. But his work also becomes an obsession. Murphy has proven he can portray that kind of inner conflict; think of his role as Robert Fischer in Inception, where he played a gifted man tormented by his father's legacy. Murphy has a unique ability to make you feel his character's inner battles, their burning desires, and their hidden vulnerabilities. He'll need it to do right by Fëanor.
Fëanor is a brilliant craftsman, a loving son, a proud father, and later, a vengeful warrior. Murphy has shown time and again that he can switch gears effortlessly. Think of him in Dunkirk, where he portrayed a shell-shocked soldier; it was a powerful performance that showed his vast range. With his proven track record of bringing depth and uniqueness to every role, Murphy would be a pristine fit for Fëanor.
3) Túrin Turambar - Liam Hemsworth
Yes, yes, Liam Hemsworth. Hear me out.
Hemsworth as Túrin Turambar is a casting choice that feels... right. Let's start with Túrin's character: he's a tragically heroic figure burdened by fate to fail yet brave in the face of it. During his eventual life, he is raised by a king of the elves (a rarity for a mortal man like him), becomes an underground fighter against Morgoth, slays the dragon Glaurung and endures a number of painful family tragedies.
Now, if you've seen Hemsworth in action, especially in roles like Gale Hawthorne in The Hunger Games series, you've witnessed how he nails the whole brooding hero vibe. There's something about the way he carries his characters' inner struggles that just screams Túrin for me. With Túrin being one of the most complex characters in The Silmarillion, someone who must deal with a cursed destiny and battling against overwhelming odds, Hemsworth's ability to portray depth and emotion while looking good is spot on. Remember how Gale was always wrestling with tough choices and trying to protect those he loved, all while carrying this weight of the world on his shoulders? That's Túrin in a nutshell.
Now, let's talk about the action-packed side of Túrin, because the guy is a warrior through and through. Hemsworth has shown time and again that he can handle physically demanding roles. Take his performance in The Expendables 2 or even his portrayal of a Navy SEAL in Extraction. In these roles, Hemsworth isn't just flexing his muscles; he's showing off some serious combat skills. Túrin is known for his expertise in battle, his swordplay, and his sheer force of will on the battlefield. Hemsworth, with his towering frame and experience in action roles, can bring all of that to life. In short, Hemsworth brings the physicality and the emotional depth needed to make Túrin's battles not just visually stunning but also emotionally touching. And, you know, good looking.
4) Beren the Renowned - Richard Madden
Who doesn't remember Richard Madden as Robb Stark in Game of Thrones? Madden played a young and noble leader thrust into a bloody political thicket, which is pretty similar to Beren's journey from a simple mortal man to a legendary hero. Madden's Robb Stark was a paragon of strength, vulnerability, and raw humanity, qualities essential for Beren, who is not just a warrior but a lover, a dreamer, and a survivor.
Madden's performance as Robb showed he could balance the intense physicality required for battle scenes with the tender, touching moments of romance and heartache. This is crucial for Beren as he engages in daring deeds all in the hope of winning the right to be with the elven princess Lúthien. There's is an impossible union, but they make it happen anyway, by overcoming impossible odds.
Madden's portrayal of David Budd in Bodyguard is another good touchstone. In that role, Madden displayed his ability to play a character carrying deep emotional scars in touch with a complex inner world. From the fierce determination in his eyes to the subtle shadow of a smile, Madden's range as an actor would breathe life into Beren's legendary adventures and his timeless romance with Lúthien.
5) Melian the Maia - Hunter Schafer
Hunter Schafer, known for her incredible performance as Jules in Euphoria, would be an impeccable choice for the role of Melian the Maia, who is the wife of the elven king Thingol, the mother of Lúthien, and one of the most powerful characters in The Silmarillion.
Schafer's portrayal of Jules puts on display her ability to embody characters who are both ethereal and profoundly emotional. Melian is a Maia, an ancient spirit who helped the Valar shape the world in the days before even the elves walked it. She has a deep connection to the natural world and a powerful, enchanting presence. That requires an actor who can bring a certain ineffable mystique. Schafer is up to the task.
In Tolkien's world, Melian isn't just a powerful person; she is also a symbol of protection, wisdom, and love. Her will creates a protective border around the forest of Doriath, where she and her husband rule their elven kingdom. Hunter Schafer, with her unique combination of otherworldliness and emotional depth, would not only embody Melian the Maia but also breathe into her a life that would resonate deeply with audiences.
6) Fingolfin - Matt Bomer
Matt Bomer, with his sharp features and intense blue eyes, is a no-brainer when it comes to who could play Fingolfin, the younger half-brother to Fëanor and the High King of the Noldor Elves after his death. He dazzled us in White Collar as the suave and clever Neal Caffrey, and that same charm and intelligence make him a perfect fit for Fingolfin, a character who combines nobility and cunning.
But it's not just about him looking damn good in a suit or outsmarting FBI agents. Bomer's role in The Normal Heart showed his ability to embody deep emotional turmoil and resilience, two traits that are essential for Fingolfin as he faces the enormous task of leading his people in a desperate struggle against Morgoth.
Fingolfin is a warrior of epic proportions. Bomer, who's wowed us with his physicality in action-packed scenes from White Collar, is up to the task of wearing armor and swinging a sword in Fingolfin's most legendary moment: challenging Morgoth -- who, I remind you, is a member of the Valar and basically a god -- to single combat. This scene needs an actor who can radiate courage, and Bomer has that for days. Imagining him standing before the gates of Morgoth's stronghold of Angband, defiant and heroic... It's the kind of scene that would have viewers on the edge of their seats, and Matt Bomer is just the actor to bring it to life.
7) Fingon - Tom Payne
Tom Payne would be an excellent choice for the role of Fingon, the son of Fingolfin and the new High King of the Noldor after his father dies during a one-on-one battle with Morgoth. Remember Payne as Jesus in The Walking Dead? Payne radiated a mix of calm, resilience and strength in that role, qualities that are tailor-made for Fingon.
Fingon is a hero with a heart of gold and a spine of steel, known for his loyalty and bravery. Payne has already shown us he looks amazing with long hair and a beard, moving with the grace of a warrior and the gentleness of a healer. His portrayal of Jesus exhibited his ability to balance inner struggles with outer composure, something Fingon -- who faces the challenge of navigating the complex politics of the Elven kingdoms -- would need in hefty amounts. Fingon is also instrumental in healing rifts between different groups of squabbling elves, something it's easy to see an actor of Payne's gifts doing convincingly.
In Prodigal Son, Payne played Malcolm Bright, a character with a deep understanding of the human psyche. The role of Fingon requires an actor who can bring that level of empathy and insight, especially when it comes to his interactions with his cousin Maedhros, whom he rescues from imprisonment atop Thangorodrim, the volcanoes that rose above Morgoth's palace of Angband. Payne's ability to convey a wide range of emotions, from intense determination to heartfelt compassion, would fit Fingon, making him a memorable and relatable character.
8) Morgoth - Michael Fassbender
Michael Fassbender, with his remarkable ability to dive into complex and dark characters, would be a spellbinding choice to play the original dark lord Morgoth, the ultimate antagonist in The Silmarillion.
Think back to his portrayal of a younger Magneto in the X-Men series. Fassbender expertly balanced the character's raw power and charisma with a deeply felt sense of betrayal and pain. In the same vein, Morgoth is not just a one-dimensional villain; he's a fallen Vala (basically a god in Tolkien lore) consumed by pride and a thirst for power, convinced he can shape the world better than Eru Ilúvatar, the ultimate creator. Fassbender's knack for playing grim, layered characters means he could embody Morgoth's transition from a mighty god with good intentions to the resentful lord of darkness. Fassbender commands the screen with a presence that is both magnetic and menacing, which is exactly what the role of Morgoth needs. Imagine him, with that intense gaze and commanding voice, forging the dark crown of Angband and leading his terrifying legions or orcs and dragons; it's a scene that Fassbender was born to bring to life.
And let's not forget Fassbender's incredible performance in Macbeth. Here, he dove deep into the depths of a character plagued by ambition, guilt, and madness. This experience is invaluable for portraying Morgoth, who much like Macbeth is driven by insatiable ambition and ultimately becomes a slave to his own corrupted desires. Fassbender's ability to evoke sympathy for even the darkest of characters means he could give Morgoth the layers he deserves, transforming him from a mere villain into a tragic, Shakespearean figure whose fall from grace is as compelling as it is catastrophic.
9) Nienor Níniel - India Eisley
India Eisley, with her enigmatic screen presence, would be a fantastic choice to play Nienor Níniel, the sister of Túrin Turambar and a character with an equally tragic destiny. Eisley, known for her roles in works like Underworld: Awakening and I Am the Night, has a remarkable ability to convey deep emotion and vulnerability, which are essential traits for Nienor. In Underworld, she navigates the complexities of being a hybrid creature caught between worlds, a trait that mirrors Nienor's own identity crisis in The Simarillion. Her portrayal of a character struggling with her nature and destiny in a dark, fantastical world is just the kind of experience that makes her perfect for the role.
Eisley's performance in the TV show I Am the Night highlights her talent for playing characters with a mysterious and troubled past. Her character is struggling to piece parts of her life together, much like Nienor must after her memory is wiped by the dragon Glaurung. Eisley's ability to embody a character who is both fragile and resilient and to portray a deep emotional journey without relying heavily on dialogue makes her an ideal fit for the role of Nienor Níniel. Her subtle acting would bring depth to Nienor, capturing the character's tragic beauty and her struggle against the inescapable shadow of fate that lies over her and her family.
10) Glaurung the dragon - Benedict Cumberbatch
Bulbasaur Cucumber will always be an angry dragon for me, so it only makes sense that I envision him as Glaurung, the first dragon ever to roam the lands of Middle-earth and one of Morgoth's chief lieutenants. Remember Buttercup Cumbersnatch as the dragon Smaug in The Hobbit? His voice turned this giant, fire-breathing beast into by far the most memorable part of this movie trilogy. He infused Smaug with a mix of arrogance, intelligence, and chilling malevolence, which is exactly what's needed for Glaurung.
Also, look how much fun he has playing dragons. Would you deny him this joy?
Glaurung is the granddaddy of all Tolkien's dragons (he's such an early prototype that he can't even fly), a creature so devious and powerful that he not only burns villages but also messes with the minds of heroes, particularly Níniel's. Bonkyhort Cutiebrunch's talent for playing characters with complex, darker edges, like his modern take on Sherlock Holmes, shows he can perfectly capture Glaurung's terrifying intellect and manipulative nature.
But it's not just his voice that makes Benadryl Cucumberpatch ideal for Glaurung. Remember him as Khan in Star Trek: Into Darkness? He was cool, calculating, and radiated a sense of superiority that you couldn't help but be drawn to despite knowing he was the bad guy. That's Glaurung in a nutshell. With Build-A-Bear Cumbersocks in the role, Glaurung would not only be a terrifying force of destruction but also a smart villain who leaves a lasting impression, turning what could have been a mere monster into a nuanced, unforgettable character.
11) Eärendil the Mariner - Austin Butler
We're almost at the end of this dream-cast, so let's check in with a character instrumental to ending the First Age of Middle-earth: Eärendil the Mariner, the first mortal to set foot in the Undying Lands beyond the sea, where dwell the Valar, the shapers of the world.
Eärendil is one of the most foundational characters in Tolkien's mythos. The child of an human man and an elven woman, he and his wife Elwing take a Silmaril and leave Middle-earth in Eärendil's ship Vingilot so they can cross the sea and beseech the gods to help the people of Middle-earth in their brutal battle against Morgoth. Because Eärendil came on behalf of the humans and elves suffering under Morgoth, rather than for himself, the king of the Valar -- Manwë -- decides that Eärendil will not be executed, the usual punishment for a mortal stepping foot in the land of the gods. Manwë marshals a host of elves who cross the sea and cast Morgoth down in the War of Wrath, which is so destructive that it reshapes the landscape of Middle-earth. Riding through the sky in Vingilot, Eärendil slays Ancalagon The Black, the most powerful of Morgothe's winged dragons, whose body crashes into and breaks the peaks of Thangorodrim above Morgoth's palace.
So Eärendil is pure-hearted, brave, heroic and very important to the story. He needs an actor of stature and presence to play him. Austin Butler, who's been on the rise thanks to high-profile roles in movies like Elvis and the upcoming Dune: Part 2, would fit the bill. Butler is young and fresh-faced enough to play a noble hero like Eärendil, but has a rugged intensity that would convince you he's capable of making a desperate, death-defying journey into dangerous waters. And because Butler is rapidly becoming a household name, casting him as Eärendil would signal to the audience something they need to know: this role matters. - Dan S
Finally, let's check in on a familiar characters from The Lord of the Rings who was also around during this period of Middle-earth's history:
12. Sauron - Charles Dance
First off, Charles Dance is incredible. He plays characters with a commanding presence, which is necessary for the role of Sauron, a fallen demi-god and Morgoth's number two man during the events of The Silmarillion. That's right: Sauron, who would one day become the dark lord of Middle-earth, was once just a lackey to someone far more powerful than him.
Dance's portrayal of Westeros' Father of the Year Tywin Lannister in Game of Thrones established him as someone who could powerful, manipulative, and intimidating figures. Unless you've been living under the mines of Moria, you know that Sauron isn't just a regular villain. He's evil. He's cunning, charismatic, and terrifyingly intelligent. Dance's performance as Tywin showcased his ability to deliver lines with a chilling calmness and a piercing gaze that could make anyone shiver. Imagine that same cold, calculating demeanor applied to Sauron, a character who manipulates and deceives entire nations. Another example is Dance's portrayal of the twisted mastermind in Underworld: Awakening.
Then there's Dance's incredible ability to express a character's internal conflicts. Sauron isn't just evil for the sake of being evil; he's a fallen Maia -- a lower class of divine being benearth the Valar -- with many layers. In The Imitation Game, Dance played Commander Denniston, a character who, while antagonistic, had dimension and depth. His ability to portray characters with an internal battle, transitioning seamlessly between cold authority and subtle vulnerability, is perfect for Sauron.
Who else would you like to see in a live-action adaptation of this epic tale? Who would you rather not see?
To stay up to date on everything fantasy, science fiction, and WiC, follow our all-encompassing Facebook page and sign up for our exclusive newsletter.
Get HBO, Starz, Showtime and MORE for FREE with a no-risk, 7-day free trial of Amazon Channels