Doctor Who: The Doctor’s Companions – Assistants vs Bosses

When it comes to companions on Doctor Who, some lean toward being assistants, while others are more bosses. What works best for the Doctor?

Earlier today, we posted an article discussing the similarities between Bill Potts and Donna Noble, each a companion to the Doctor at different times in his life. Among their strong suits are making practical observations and challenging the way that the Doctor conducts himself. In reality, these are traits that all of his companions have had to possess to one degree or another. Some are just better at it than others.

In an interview with Paul Simper of The Sun‘s TV Magazine this past Saturday, showrunner Steven Moffat answers a question about how Nardole has developed since his first appearance in last year’s ‘The Husbands of River Song.’ His answer takes an interesting turn, going beyond the usual discussion regarding this character.

More from Winter is Coming

Moffat touches on the point that the Doctor does not have the same power dynamic with all of his companions — some are more bosses than assistants. This train of thought was inspired by a conversation that Moffat had with a young girl who is a fan of the show. In response to being asked if she would like to be the Doctor, she said that she would prefer to be Amy Pond because she was his boss. Moffat agrees with this assessment of their relationship.

He also expands on the previously discussed topic of Nardole being the Doctor’s valet (or butler, depending on the interview). His thought is that this particular incarnation of the “Doctor likes having a valet that’s a bit sardonic and gives him an a**e kicking from time to time, and that’s Nardole.” The Doctor may be loath to admit it, but he seems to like this treatment from his companions in general, whether from an assistant or a boss.

(Article continues below the next post link.)

Next: Doctor Who Parodies: The Twelve Doctors of Christmas

Ultimately, each of the Doctor’s companions tend to be a combination of assistant and boss, each individual leaning more strongly one way or the other, some even changing over time. What dynamic do you prefer? Give us your thoughts in the comments below.