Jesse Q. Sutanto has made her dark fantasy debut with An Edge Sharp Enough, which is a very different reading experience from the books many readers will know her for.
It is dark, ambitious and filled with characters whose lives become increasingly tangled as the story progresses. From political conspiracies and ancient magic to forbidden love and the consequences of a buried history, there is plenty here to keep fantasy readers invested.
Meet Mara, an assassin with a different kind of strength
One of the central characters is Mara, a young woman raised at the Institute, where children are trained to become Emissaries and carry out dangerous assignments. She is physically frail, which makes her position in an institution built around strength and obedience particularly difficult.
However, Mara has an extraordinary understanding of Artifices — objects capable of harnessing magic — and her abilities make her considerably more dangerous than people might initially assume.
Her relationship with Lia is another important part of her story. The two share a connection that complicates the expectations placed upon them, particularly in an environment where affection and personal attachments can become liabilities. Their relationship gives Mara's chapters an emotional dimension that balances the brutality of her circumstances.
I particularly liked that Mara's vulnerability is not treated as something that makes her less interesting. She has plenty of anger, determination and complicated feelings, and those qualities make her easy to invest in. Her story also raises interesting questions about what it means to be strong in a world that has very specific ideas about who deserves power.
Four perspectives make for a bigger story
Beyond Mara, the novel follows Livya Bellevue, Kaian Xi and Commander Fonde, three characters whose circumstances introduce readers to another side of the conflict.
Livya is a scholar whose family is closely connected to the development of adther, a metal that has become essential to the prosperity of Velingard. Kaian, her childhood friend, brings a different perspective to their investigation, while Commander Fonde finds himself dealing with problems that reach far beyond his responsibilities as a military leader.
I enjoyed seeing how these characters approach the events unfolding around them. Their individual circumstances gave us different insights into the political and social structures of the world, and obviously their storylines gradually intersect with Mara's. Each has their own reasons for getting involved, which makes the shift between perspectives worthwhile.
The magic system and worldbuilding are major highlights
The magic system is one of the strongest aspects of An Edge Sharp Enough. Art is woven into the world's history, religion and political structure, and its disappearance has had consequences that extend far beyond the people who can use it.
I also enjoyed the contrast between the older forms of magic and the society that has developed around adther. There is a sense that the world has built its understanding of power on incomplete information, and learning more about its history changes how we view the present conflict.
Sutanto gives the setting a strong sense of history through its old beliefs, forgotten stories and political institutions. The darker elements fit naturally into this world, too. The Institute's treatment of its students and the suppression of magic help establish an atmosphere in which survival often comes at a considerable cost.
A story about love, loneliness and survival
For all its magic and political intrigue, the emotional side of the novel is what gives it much of its identity. Loneliness runs through the different perspectives, although it manifests differently for each character. Some are isolated by the positions they occupy, while others struggle with expectations, personal attachments and the feeling that they do not quite belong.
Mara and Lia's relationship is particularly important in this regard. Their connection is so important to the story that could otherwise become consumed by its darker political and magical conflicts. It also makes the question of what characters are willing to sacrifice for the people they love considerably more personal.
I found this balance between the larger fantasy plot and the characters' individual experiences to be one of the book's biggest strengths. The stakes are high, but the story gives us reasons to care about the people caught in the middle of them.

Verdict
An Edge Sharp Enough is an ambitious and engaging dark fantasy that gives Jesse Q. Sutanto plenty of room to explore a different side of her storytelling. Its memorable characters, unusual magic system and political intrigue make for a very intriguing and rewarding read!
The opening requires some patience as the different storylines come together. There is a fair amount of information to absorb, and the novel occasionally asks readers to sit with unanswered questions. However, the payoff makes that investment worthwhile.
This is also a book that makes me curious about what Sutanto has planned next. There is clearly more to explore in this world, and the story leaves enough unresolved to make the continuation an exciting prospect.
For readers looking for a fantasy with morally complicated characters, forbidden love, political intrigue and a magic system with plenty of history behind it, An Edge Sharp Enough is well worth picking up. It may be a departure from the cozy mysteries and contemporary stories that introduced many readers to Sutanto, but it is a very welcome one.
