Skip to main content

One of Star Trek: Voyager's most thought-provoking episodes turns 29 today

Captain Janeway was faced with a very unconventional problem in 1997.
ByDaniel Bibby
Star Trek Explorer courtesy of Titan Books

Perhaps best known as being the "weirdest" Star Trek series due to the string of bizarre occurrences that Captain Janeway (Kate Mulgrew) and her crew endured, Voyager also had more than its fair share of deeply philosophical outings. For every race of extradimensional aliens flooding into the Delta Quadrant to attack the ship, there was often a mission that was decidedly less violent and more thoughtful.

Star Trek: Voyager was (and still is) unique for being the franchise's only project set almost entirely away from the Alpha Quadrant. As such, Janeway and company were constantly making First Contact with new alien races, and forced to adapt to customs and traditions they hadn't prepared for. Some of them were more extreme and difficult to navigate than others. One such instance arrived in 1997 during season 4's "Random Thoughts."

Star Trek: Voyager
Photo: Star Trek: Voyager 25th Anniversary Special.. Image Courtesy Titan Comics | Titans Comics

"Random Thoughts" is '90s sci-fi TV at its best

One of the defining characteristics of sci-fi in the 1990s is that the genre was thriving on the big screen, and TV shows were often trying to replicate that success on a much smaller budget. There were flashes of success in this respect, but classic shows like Star Trek were always far better at smaller, character-driven storylines rather than big set pieces.

I always found these more intimate efforts were especially effective when it was clear the producers had far less money to play with than usual. "Random Thoughts" definitely comes across as one of those. Set mostly on the Mari homeworld, the planet and its people were fairly basic as far as production design goes. The Mari themselves were little more than telepathic humans by a different name, and their planet looked every inch the penny-pinching '90s sci-fi TV set.

Note: "Random Thoughts" premiered on UPN on Nov. 19, 1997.

Still, the airtight premise did some very heavy lifting to make "Random Thoughts" into a compelling episode. In short, the Mari had outlawed thoughts that could be deemed dark, violent, or unsavory in any way. The logic behind this is that their telepathic nature made it too easy for those thoughts to be passed on to other members of the Mari species, and even if the thought's originator doesn't act on them, the recipient might.

In episodes that weren't quite so bound by paltry finances, I have my doubts that such an interesting script would have materialized. Given TV's spirited attempts to be more cinematic in the 1990s to compete with the booming sci-fi movie industry, the knee-jerk response from TV writers was to go big and bold as often as possible. Voyager certainly had a few impressive outings like that, but installments like "Random Thoughts" prove that variety was key.

Why "Random Thoughts" is still one of Star Trek: Voyager's most provocative episodes

At first, the episode comes across as a mildly philosophical sci-fi jape. However, scratch even a little beneath the surface and things get deeply philosophical. According to Mari law, the originator of a violent thought is deemed guilty of the act it leads to, even if it's another Mari who commits the physical act of attacking or killing someone. Then, the thought's originator undergoes an invasive procedure called an engrammatic purge.

This, on its own, already feels problematic, but it can be easily justified by remembering that this is a race of alien telepaths, and that thoughts can be infectious and therefore dangerous in such a society. That said, it's not even the perfect solution that the Mari leadership believes it to be.

Where "Random Thoughts" ranks on IMDb's list of all 168 Star Trek: Voyager episodes

Ranking

Title

Season

Episode

Year

IMDb Score

#127

"Mortal Coil"

4

12

1999

6.8/10

#128

"Nemesis"

4

4

1999

6.8/10

#129

"Random Thoughts"

4

10

1999

6.8/10

#130

"Alter Ego"

3

14

1998

6.7/10

#131

"Concerning Flight"

4

11

1999

6.7/10

#132

"Emanations"

1

8

1996

6.7/10

With violent and dark thoughts outlawed, a black market trade in those kinds of ruminations arises to satisfy those who feel they want or need them. In other words, the Mari don't rid their society of its problem; they just unknowingly banish it to the shadows where they can't monitor or prevent it.

So, "Random Thoughts" quickly becomes an allegory for censorship, personal responsibility, as well as laws and regulations that may seem well-meaning, but are so optimistic and poorly considered that they actually make the problem they're trying to solve even worse. These were all hot topics in the 90s as much as they are today. While the episode's visuals have aged, the themes have not.

Anson Mount as Captain Pike in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, episode 6, season 4. Photo Credit: Jan Thijs/Paramount+
Anson Mount as Captain Pike in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, episode 6, season 4. Photo Credit: Jan Thijs/Paramount+ | Jan Thijs/Paramount+

Why modern Star Trek often fails to recapture this particular brand of thoughtfulness

Star Trek: Discovery kickstarted a new age of storytelling for the franchise. Rather than 20+ episodes per season, where each episode almost always featured a standalone plot, new Star Trek series started coming in seasons roughly 10 episodes long and heavily serialized. So, everything now tends to be written to slot into a broader storyline rather than a show being able to go back and forth between often quite disparate themes and messages.

Newer Star Trek shows do still find time to explore philosophical concepts, but they're almost always hyper-specific to a certain character. For instance, the idea that Captain Pike (Anson Mount) has to find ways to cope with leadership while knowing what's waiting for him in his future opens up some fascinating conversations. They're not exactly universal, though.

Voyager was a sort of hybrid, like the other 90s Star Trek shows, in that it tried to stay accessible so that anyone could tune in on a week-to-week basis, while also pushing a more cohesive narrative forward as the ship edged closer to Earth. In the streaming era, dense and overarching narratives are the priority to keep people engaged in the age of on-demand TV. As a result, "filler" episodes, like "Random Thoughts," have become relics of a bygone age for Star Trek.

Paramount+ is the streaming home of Star Trek.

Add us as a preferred source on Google