The Dark Wizard, whose identity was teased in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 2, has been revealed as Pallando (Ciarán Hinds), one of the two Blue Wizards from J.R.R. Tolkien’s books. But in season 3, viewers may notice he’s looking less and less dark with every passing moment. He’s looking less sinister and more uncertain, less cruel and more tired.
Gandalf (Daniel Weyman), in fact, was sent to save him, and Gandalf is known as a good influence. So perhaps he is rubbing off on Pallando. Here’s why that makes sense, and why it could be a really important part of this story.
What Tolkien really thought of the Blue Wizards
Tolkien changed his mind about the Blue Wizards more than once. In a 1958 letter, he feared they had failed, as Saruman did, and founded secret cults in the East that outlasted Sauron’s fall. That earlier, darker vision is the one The Rings of Power drew on for the Dark Wizard and his cult-like following in Rhûn.
But in Tolkien’s latest writings, the Blue Wizards were good, not bad. Pallando’s redemption arc may end up honouring Tolkien’s final thoughts on the subject. Not just that, but in this text, the Blue Wizards helped stop the growth of Sauron’s forces in the East. Some of you may not know this, especially given the pace of Sauron’s advance in season 3, but Sauron (Charlie Vickers) is heading for a severe humbling.

Sauron is heading for a fall
Sauron is growing ever more powerful, and we know his forging of the One Ring will succeed. But we also know from The Silmarillion that Númenor’s growing power will come to rival his. And in fact, as The Rings of Power season 3 is starting to show, Pharazôn (Trystan Gravelle) is getting a bit big for his boots. Jealous of what he sees as just some sorcerer getting powerful in Middle-earth, Pharazôn is primed for some colonial expansion.
The Akallabêth chapter of The Silmarillion tells how Pharazôn, in his arrogance and, let’s be real, total folly, sailed with a huge armada to Middle-earth to confront Sauron. In the books, this happens well over a thousand years after the Ring is forged, but The Rings of Power has never been shy about compressing Tolkien’s timeline. Cue what will likely be an epic season 4 storyline.
Sauron, at this point, can’t actually contend with Númenor’s forces, and he is subdued by Pharazôn. But, being Sauron, he sets off a chain of events that, surprise, surprise, does not end so well for Pharazôn.

Why one island could humble a Dark Lord
But as The Rings of Power season 3 is demonstrating, Sauron’s forces have swept rapidly across Middle-earth by this point. So what’s to stop him from taking on Númenor, which is just one island? Firstly, Númenor is the greatest maritime civilisation in the legendarium, and a nation of long-lived Men descended from the Edain. Many may recall how Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen) is looking good for his age (87) in Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings movies. The Dúnedain are descended from the Númenóreans and inherited their exceptionally long lifespans.
But also, if Tolkien’s later writings are to be adapted, the Blue Wizards’ hard work in the East may be part of what keeps Sauron from defeating Númenor. In The Peoples of Middle-earth, Tolkien lays out this version of the Blue Wizards’ history. He says they must have had “very great influence on the history of the Second Age.” In this version, they weaken and scatter the forces of the East, which would otherwise have far outnumbered the West.
There’s a catch for the show. In that late note, Tolkien gives the Blue Wizards different names, Morinehtar and Rómestámo, meaning “Darkness-slayer” and “East-helper.” So a redeemed Pallando could be the show’s way of uniting Tolkien’s two visions in one character: a wizard who fell, then came back to do exactly what the Professor finally asked of him.

Will Pallando choose the light?
The Rings of Power is making up a noncanonical Second Age quest for Gandalf, and it seems to be boiling down to redeeming Pallando. Everything seems to point to his redemption. If it comes, the stakes go far beyond one wizard’s soul. A Pallando who turns against Sauron could keep Rhûn’s armies out of Mordor’s ranks. That could be what tips the balance and leaves Sauron weak enough to be humbled by Pharazôn’s armada.
But it isn’t too late for Pallando to remain the Dark Wizard for all eternity, choosing Sauron over Gandalf. Whichever way he turns, Middle-earth’s future may turn with him.
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3 is streaming now on Prime Video, with the final two episodes arriving on November 25. For more on the season’s new faces, see our guide to the new characters coming in season 3.
