If you’re part of the devoted Witcher fanbase, you’ve probably scoured every inch of Velen, mastered every sign, and made every morally ambiguous decision that Geralt’s story has to offer.
But now that you’ve poured hours into the series, you’re likely left with the burning question every gamer dreads asking: “What do I play next?” Well, you’re in luck because there’s still a whole buffet of games that deliver a Witcher-esque mix of narrative depth, rich worlds, and gripping combat. And no, you don’t have to replay The Witcher 3 for the millionth time (unless you really want to).
For fans of Geralt-sized adventures, here are three games that might just fill that Witcher-shaped void in your heart (and your hard drive).
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Keyword tie-in? Check. Endless mods? Double check.
Okay, recommending Skyrim to Witcher fans feels a little like saying, “If you like steak, try chicken nuggets,” but hear me out. For all of its meme-worthy quirks (hello, “arrow to the knee”), Skyrim nails what The Witcher series thrives on: a sprawling world where you decide who you want to be.
Want to be a noble hero vanquishing dragons? Cool. Prefer to slink around as a morally dubious, lock-picking assassin? Totally valid. While its storytelling doesn’t hit Witcher-level “punch you in the soul with emotion,” Skyrim offers unparalleled freedom in its open-world shenanigans. Plus, if Geralt’s contracts weren’t enough, you’ll adore slaying dragons and hoarding way too many potions in your inventory.
And hey, with mods galore, it’s basically a “Choose Your Own Witcher Adventure.” Seriously, there’s probably a Geralt skin out there somewhere. Go wild.
Horizon Zero Dawn
Imagine if Ciri had a bow and was hunting robot dinosaurs—that’s practically this game.
If you loved the sweeping vistas of The Witcher and its meticulously crafted open world, Horizon Zero Dawn is going to be your new BFF. Guerrilla Games managed to hit us with a double whammy in this masterpiece by giving us two things Witcher fans crave deeply: a stunning open-world experience and a strong, compelling protagonist. Aloy isn’t Geralt (no one is), but she brings enough enthusiasm, wit, and cool-headed determination to keep you fully invested.
Instead of wraiths or drowners, you’ll be battling sleek, mechanical beasts that look like they were assembled by a sci-fi design team with a fondness for riddles. The combat system is fluid, strategic, and yes, gloriously over-the-top. Plot twists lurk around every corner of this post-apocalyptic yet oddly beautiful future. Honestly? If you’re into Witcher-level storytelling and jaw-dropping landscapes, you’ll feel right at home here. And the robot dinos? Just a killer bonus.
Red Dead Redemption 2
All roads lead to moral ambiguity, apparently.
Geralt, meet Arthur Morgan. Arthur, meet Geralt. You two are going to get along great. If your favorite kind of Witcher experience is heartfelt storytelling, realistic characters, and a load of morally grey decisions, Red Dead Redemption 2 is about to be your jam. Unlike Geralt, though, you won’t find Arthur slashing through ghouls—but you will get gritty shootouts, high-stakes heists, and really intense showdowns involving cowboy hats.
The world in Red Dead Redemption 2 has that layered, lived-in feel that Witcher fans adore. You can spend days wrapping yourself in side quests or simply soak in the warmth of campfire conversations. Big bonus? Like Geralt, Arthur’s personality depends on you. You can play him as a cruel outcast or a surprisingly decent guy with a shot at redemption. The emotional impact? 10/10 on the heartbreak scale.
If these three games don’t scratch that Witcher itch entirely, don’t feel bad about giving Geralt another spin. And hey, until The Witcher 4 arrives, these games will ensure your open-world cravings and love for morally complex characters stay well-fed.
More Witcher:
To stay up to date on everything fantasy, science fiction, and WiC, follow our all-encompassing Facebook page and Twitter account, sign up for our exclusive newsletter, and check out our YouTube channel.