Skip to main content

George R.R. Martin & Tad Williams agree: J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth is the 'greatest' worldbuilding in fantasy

Two of the fantasy genre's most prominent authors nerd out about J.R.R. Tolkien, and explain why the depth of worldbuilding for Middle-earth remains unmatched.
ByDaniel Roman
The Art of The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien: The Complete Collection of Original Illustrations and Paintings for the Classic 75th Anniversary Edition.
The Art of The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien: The Complete Collection of Original Illustrations and Paintings for the Classic 75th Anniversary Edition. | Image: William Morrow.

Right now, Prime Video is in the thick of airing the third season of its Lord of the Rings television show The Rings of Power, sweeping fans back to Middle-earth for a brand new adventure based on the Second Age of J.R.R. Tolkien's legendarium. Tolkien is the grandfather of modern fantasy; without his Middle-earth, it's impossible to know what the genre would look like today. Truly, his influence can't be understated.

Two young upstart writers who were deeply impacted by Tolkien in their early days are George R.R. Martin and Tad Williams, the authors of A Song of Ice and Fire and Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn, respectively. In a video released by Williams' publisher DAW books last month to celebrate the release of his new Osten Ard book The Splintered Sun, Williams and Martin got into a cheerful discussion about all the ways Tolkien had informed their own writing, and the genre at large.

For both Martin and Williams, Tolkien caught them utterly by surprise. Both were readers of sword and sorcery fantasy books in the vein of Robert E. Howard's Conan the Barbarian. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings books were a different beast entirely, and much of that came down to the sheer depth and scale of his worldbuilding, which Williams and Martin are in agreement is still the best to ever come out of the fantasy genre.

Why Tolkien's worldbuilding remains the "greatest" in fantasy

"Tolkien's creation of Middle-earth is one of the really great worldbuilding things ever done in fantasy. The greatest, I think," said Martin.

"Yeah, it has to be," agreed Williams.

"And I wasn't prepared for that, because reading with sword and sorcery as a grade school kid and a junior high kid, there's not much depth to the history," Martin continued. "There are writers who don't even make an attempt. They'll just begin with a 'once upon a time there was a king, and he lived in this country, and across from his country was elf-land, where the elves lived or something.' And that's fine. That was a tradition for hundreds of years and some good writers use that kind of thing, and certainly you see the influence of those writers on like Disney and Disney movies."

"But you know...reading the Tolkien books, I remember when the Ring went into Mount Doom and [I thought] this book is over now...but wait, there's all these other pages," he recalled. "What are all these other pages? What they were of course were the Scouring of Shire, which I really appreciate now but I did not appreciate back then, I didn't know what the hell was going on. And then pages and pages and pages of appendices, of kings that have been dead for a thousand years and kingdoms that are long gone since into the sea and mythology...there was so much depth there. It's like the world was real to Tolkien, and it became real to me, you know, reading it. And certainly that is something that I wanted to work in that tradition, and also the tradition of historical fiction when I started mine."

Ships sail into the bay of NĂºmenor in The Rings of Power.
NĂºmenor in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. | Courtesy Amazon Studios

It's extra fun to hear Martin talk about those appendices that he found so intriguing right now, because they are largely what Amazon's show The Rings of Power is based on. That "kingdom that is long gone since into the sea" is of course NĂºmenor, which fills a central part of the series. Before now, much of the appendix material as well as the story laid out in The Silmarillion were largely the territory of only the most diehard of Tolkien fans. Now they're being brought into the mainstream.

Martin added that Williams' own work on the fantasy world of Osten Ard predates Westeros, and its worldbuilding was also a cut above many others. "I think, Osten Ard, you had worldbuilding...you were also influenced by Tolkien, you weren't just 'once upon a time there was a kingdom.' You had genealogies and history and a revolt here and all of that stuff."

Williams detailed some of his own worldbuilding process, and how it essentially moves in stages, with much of the basic worldbuilding done up front, and then more and more added as he needs it while he's writing the story.

"It's very much a process of the worldbuilding grows along with the story — unlike Tolkien," Williams said. "One of the things I think all of us fantasy writers are probably willing to admit is none of us is ever going to go into the depth that Tolkien wrote."

Daemon (Matt Smith) and Rhaenyra Targaryen (Emma D'Arcy) speak in High Valyrian on House of the Dragon.
Daemon (Matt Smith) and Rhaenyra Targaryen (Emma D'Arcy) speak in High Valyrian on House of the Dragon. | Photograph by Ollie Upton/HBO.

Tolkien is still the master of fictional languages

There's one place in particular that both Martin and Williams are in full agreement that Tolkien may never be matched: his fictional languages, like Elvish and the Black Speech of Mordor. While Westeros and Osten Ard both feature fictional languages, the actual behind-the-scenes development done on them doesn't hold a candle to the sheer depth of what Tolkien created.

"People ask me, 'How do you do your languages?' The answer is: I don't do them," Williams said. "I essentially take bits and pieces from languages that are appropriate and then I modify them. Whereas, obviously, as we fantasy fans know, Tolkien actually invented languages. I'm not capable of that, and he spent 50 years doing that."

"I was not capable of that either," Martin said. "I invented High Valyrian and the Old Tongue, and I invented about eight words of each. But then at a certain point when the TV show [came along] and all that, they actually hired a language invention guy, David Peterson, he's marvelous. And now I have to consult him when I want to write anything in High Valyrian because you know, he's invented a lexicon and 10,000 words. [Laughs] I still have my eight, but whatever."

"He's now the world's leading expert," Williams joked.

The cover of The Art of The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien. It features a watercolor painting by the author of the Lonely Mountain.
The Art of The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien: The Complete Collection of Original Illustrations and Paintings for the Classic 75th Anniversary Edition. | Image: William Morrow.

J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth has always been regarded as one of the densest, most thoroughly built fantasy worlds by fans, but it's still fun to hear two of the leading authors in the genre nerd out about it just like the rest of us. With The Rings of Power speeding toward immensely important moments from those appendices which inspired young George R.R. Martin all those years ago, there's never been a better time to read some of the extended works in Tolkien's legendarium.

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power is streaming now on Prime Video. Tad Williams' latest Osten Ard novel, The Splintered Sun, is available now wherever books are sold.

Add us as a preferred source on Google