Skip to main content

Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2 episode 9 recap and review: 'Another Man's Shadow'

The story takes us far from the shadows of the main couples in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2 episode 9.
ByNoelle Mazzoni
Sam Retford (“Dougal MacKenzie”) and Séamus McLean Ross (“Colum MacKenzie”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2.
Sam Retford (“Dougal MacKenzie”) and Séamus McLean Ross (“Colum MacKenzie”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2. | Photo: Robert Wilson/Starz.

As the penultimate episode of Outlander: Blood of My Blood’s sophomore season, “Another Man’s Shadow” delivers one of the most emotionally heavy moments of the series — this time, far from our two main couples.

While Ellen MacKenzie (Harriet Slater) and Brian Fraser (Jamie Roy) begin to thrive away from their dysfunctional families, and Julia (Hermione Corfield) and Henry Beauchamp (Jeremy Irvine) return to their respective lives in the 18th century, tragedy strikes at Leoch.

Colum MacKenzie (Séamus McLean Ross) and his wife Letitia’s (Rebekah Lumsden) child is born deformed and passes away soon after. He is not the only person to meet an untimely demise: John Cameron (Alastair Mackenzie), Jocasta MacKenzie’s (Sadhbh Malin) husband, “falls” from the stairs and dies.

However, neither one of these situations is as it seems.

Conor MacNeill (“Ned Gowan”), Séamus McLean Ross (“Colum MacKenzie”), and Sam Retford (“Dougal MacKenzie”).
Conor MacNeill (“Ned Gowan”), Séamus McLean Ross (“Colum MacKenzie”), and Sam Retford (“Dougal MacKenzie”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2. | Photo: Robert Wilson/Starz.

Tragedy at Leoch

Colum and Letitia’s child is born deformed. Because Mrs. Fitzgibbons (Sally Messham) opens a window during the delivery — which is a call for bad luck — they are convinced the baby is a changeling, a creature that fairies supposedly leave in place of a human child. Letitia ardently believes this and refuses to hold the baby or even look at it. The child’s cradle is moved to the chapel instead.

Colum takes the baby to the faerie hill (probably the same hill we see in Outlander season 1) in the hopes their real child will be returned to them. The next morning, he goes back to the hill, but finds the baby dead.

Colum might have not passed on his condition voluntarily, but he did leave him to die in the cold. His mother, Letitia, also didn’t help. She refused to acknowledge him as her own child and forced Colum to abandon him in the cold of the night, in a desperate attempt to “find” her real child.

Their behavior is understandable given the time and place. But they indeed brought on their child’s untimely death, even though he would’ve surely eventually died from his sickness.

This, Colum understands. And along with his son’s death, he also has to grieve the “death” of his marriage. By denying Letitia their intimacy, he effectively closes off any connection with his wife.

Maura urges Dougal (Sam Retford) to claim the MacKenzie seat while Colum is grieving and to step out of “another’s man shadow,” — his brother’s — referencing the episode’s title. What’s infuriating is that he doesn’t refuse her request: he sits and entertains his tenants, successfully showing himself as a leader not just on the battlefield. He and Maura (Bobby Rainsbury) are ecstatic until Colum talks with Dougal about the baby.

Colum confesses to Dougal that he knew his child wasn’t a changeling, that it was genes that made the child deformed, and that he won’t sleep with Letitia again for fear of putting her through the same heartache. He also reappoints Dougal as his war chieftain, finally bridging the two brothers into a newfound understanding.

Maura tells Dougal she’s pregnant. In the Outlander books, Jamie tells Claire that Dougal and Maura have four daughters together, the eldest being named Molly, whom he had a childhood crush on. Might this be that same daughter?

Alastair Mackenzie ("John Cameron") and Sadhbh Mailn (“Jocasta MacKenzie Cameron”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2.
Alastair Mackenzie ("John Cameron") and Sadhbh Mailn (“Jocasta MacKenzie Cameron”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2. | Photo: Robert Wilson/Starz.

John Cameron’s demise

At the Cameron estate, Murtagh (Rory Alexander) waits for Grace (Ruby Fubara) in their secret meeting place, but she never shows up. To make sure she’s alright, he goes to her room, and just in time to save her from John Cameron, who has once again forced Grace into bed with him. A fight ensues, and Murtagh accidentally throws John Cameron against a dresser, where he suffers a fatal head injury. In the aftermath, Jocasta stumbles upon the chaotic scene, finding out about Grace and Murtagh’s love affair.

She has Murtagh move the body to the bottom of the stairs, where he is found by a servant. Jocasta pretends to be shocked and covers for Murtagh. John’s cousin, Hugh (Bryan Dick), however, is suspicious of the circumstances and immediately suspects Jocasta: it seems like Hugh knew about his cousin’s preference for Grace, and so deduces that Jocasta might have killed her husband because she was jealous.

Under the pressure of Hugh’s inquiries, Jocasta convinces Grace to flee Scotland and gives her money for passage to the Americas. She also talks Murtagh out of going after her to avoid looking guilty. She lies to him and tells him that Hugh suspects Grace.

But Hugh knows the facts don’t add up. As part of an ultimatum, he swears he will play along only if Jocasta agrees to marry him, effectively becoming the owner of his cousin’s estate and business.

Tony Curran (“Simon Fraser ‘Lord Lovat’”) and Simon Merrells (“Uncle Malcolm Grant”).
Tony Curran (“Simon Fraser ‘Lord Lovat’”) and Simon Merrells (“Uncle Malcolm Grant”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2. | Photo: Robert Wilson/Starz.

Lovat lays his scheme

Lovat has a meeting with Lord Grant and assures him that his marriage to Julia will be ended soon. Grant then asks Henry to draw up a marriage contract between Lovat and his sister Margaret Grant. This proves Julia’s suspicions were right and that she and Henry need to find a way out of the 18th century as soon as possible.

That leaves a big question. Is one episode enough to close this storyline? The season finale might leave fans hanging and wanting more on Julia and Henry’s outcome.

Jamie Roy (“Brian Fraser”) and Harriet Slater (“Ellen MacKenzie”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2.
Jamie Roy (“Brian Fraser”) and Harriet Slater (“Ellen MacKenzie”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood season 2. | Photo: Robert Wilson/Starz.

Interruption in paradise

In what I think is an early version of what will become Lallybroch, we find Ellen and Brian finally living their dream married life. She washes him while he soaks in the bathtub, he flirts with her, and they are absolutely sickening together — but that we like! Ellen and Brian are finally able to be in love on their own terms, in their home, away from judging eyes, and free from Lovat’s control.

To interrupt the peace of their love nest comes a messenger bearing the gift of an invitation to the Twelfth Night festivities. Also known as Wassailing (meaning “good health” from Old English), Twelfth Night in Scotland marks the traditional end of the festive season and the eve of Epiphany, but it has pagan roots. Ellen points out the masked tradition, which might come from William Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night, a comedy with a very renowned theme of disguise.

Fearing a meeting with their families, Brian decides they will not go to the Twelfth Night festivities. Ellen, albeit initially excited about the prospect, eventually agrees.

Another interruption manifests in the form of Ned Gowan, bearing gifts. He gives Ellen her mother’s wedding dress and tells them about Colum and Letitia’s loss. He encourages her to read the note from Colum, which has her mother’s ring in it: a peace sign, and a bridge to reconnect, in case she wishes to. This leads to Brian and Ellen deciding to go to the festivities, which we will see next week.

Séamus McLean Ross (“Colum MacKenzie”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood.
Séamus McLean Ross (“Colum MacKenzie”) in Outlander: Blood of My Blood. | Photo: Robert Wilson/Starz.

Verdict

“Another Man’s Shadow” definitely shifts the emotional and storytelling focus onto secondary characters of the Outlander prequel. This might have easily weighed down the episode and let the viewers down, but I found it both emotionally engaging and personally satisfying.

Most of all, the secondary plotlines are actually quite important and a focal point of the Outlander lore. This episode showcased how Colum ended up having no heirs of “his own” until just a few years before Claire first travelled through the stones — more than 20 years after the events of Blood of My Blood. It also explained how Jocasta came to marry another Cameron, this time the calculating Hugh.

So, even though this episode didn’t focus on the main characters, it still delivered an enjoyable and satisfying continuation of the season. It also brought some plotlines closer to their end, which we will surely see on our screens next week, for the final episode of season 2.

The highlight of this episode was Séamus McLean Ross’ performance as a grieving Colum. Let’s say that Colum has been grieving since the beginning of the show: first for the death of his father, then for his brother competing for the lairdship, and then for his sister walking out of his life after mistreating her.

This time, Colum has to grieve for his own child: his son and heir, born deformed and sickly, who died both because of his father’s condition and the folk tales of the time. Séamus McLean Ross portrays this deepened emotion in Colum’s character masterfully. Every scene of Colum in this episode displayed his dwindling self-worth and growing weakness.

The stage is set for an intriguing season finale; there is plenty left to tell. I can't wait to see how it all unfolds and how Outlander: Blood of My Blood will conclude its sophomore season.

Grade: B+

Add us as a preferred source on Google