Spoilers lie ahead for The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3, episode 5.
In Prime Video's The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3, episode 5, Ciarán Hinds is coming into his own as Pallando. He looks older and older, and more sympathetic the older he looks. This depth works for an ancient Istar. Gandalf (Daniel Weyman) never visited Pallando in Rhûn, where the Wizard is slowly succumbing to Sauron via the influence of Khamûl the Easterling (Zubin Varla). But these are legendarium figures acting in character, and it’s fun. That’s the general approach of this episode. Occasionally, it takes a pinch of the best salt in the Shire to see the Tolkien in it, but showrunners J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay sure are cooking.
Hail Adar
Marnûkh (Adam Young) is an original character, so obviously Sauron (Charlie Vickers) never tortured him for information on Galadriel’s whereabouts in the books. Does Sauron torture canonically, though? Why, yes. Gollum can confirm.
We don’t mean to emasculate Adar, whose season 2 redemption arc was a highlight, but he got totally fridged for this Orc. Fridging is when women in film or TV are killed off for someone else’s character development or as a plot device. We’re not saying his death wasn’t perfect. But if all it did was teach Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) to say “Uruk” so she could have a civil adventure with this Orc, we’re team #AdarDeservedBetter.
But in seriousness, on close inspection, Adar’s Marnûkh-shaped legacy is actually one of the best examples of the show engaging with Tolkien themes through original material. Tolkien never stopped being curious about Orc morality. Marnûkh says it best on the rack, to Sauron’s dismay: “Hail Adar.”

Double Aramayo please
And now, drumroll please. Enter Elros. This is season 3’s next Anárion moment, the first-ever adaptation of a key legendarium character. In the books, Elros is Elrond’s twin. Given the choice between the fates of Elves and Men, he chose mortality and became the first King of Númenor. The outstanding Robert Aramayo (anyone seen I Swear?) plays both twins, Elrond and Elros, in this flashback. Aramayo turning to Aramayo for a chat is hilarious for some indiscernible reason, whether excitement or uncanny valley. But it lands. We’re not sure where, but it lands.
Cut to the present: Elrond and Gil-galad (Benjamin Walker) sail to Númenor, as never happened in the books. However, ships docking in the Bay of Rómenna, with Númenor’s theme soaring higher than the sails, is not a thing that gets old in this show. And if it did, shame on The Rings of Power. Númenor was the greatest maritime civilisation in the legendarium, and its televisation is, in large part, what we are here for. Pharazôn’s (Trystan Gravelle) growing arrogance and decadence in this episode is also everything it needs to be to match his tyranny in the Akallabêth, making season 4 an exciting prospect.

Galadriel’s rival suitors
Celeborn reveals to Galadriel that he survived the flames of Ancalagon, who set his legion on fire in the War of Wrath, only to be imprisoned in Thangorodrim until it fell. Ancalagon and Thangorodrim are but footnotes in LotR and its appendices, with their whole story fleshed out in The Silmarillion. Often diving deep into lore, there are so many legendarium rights victories in this season, the show killed it deader than Ancalagon when he copped a blow from Eärendil at the end of the war. The only canon bend here is Celeborn's presence in these Silmarillion scenes, which was just as likely as not.
As a prisoner, Celeborn saw Galadriel passing and called to her, but she thought he was a hallucination, consumed by her task of hunting Sauron. Celeborn asks if Galadriel had a special someone in his absence. She says no, which is just as comical as when she said she hadn’t seen Sauron in five years to Arondir before falling asleep and psychically connecting to him immediately.
Celeborn presses Galadriel for information on this other man that she definitely didn’t have in his absence, and we get “He is not welcome in this moment, do not want him here” and “He was all I had left.” Then she dreams she’s cuddling Sauron, although that could just be his psychic attention reaching a fever pitch. This telenovela is no Tolkien, but Aulë's arse, the tea is hot. And it is spilling.
For those who like their canon bendy
Sauron finds Celeborn and Galadriel, but Galadriel remains hidden. It turns out Sauron rode Ancalagon when he torched Celeborn’s legion in the War of Wrath. Not canon, but there’s no reason why not, and it’s a pretty awesome image. Celeborn is to be taken hostage.
At this point, Sauron says: “She’ll come to you, but she’ll come for me.” Anyone seen the part of RuPaul’s Drag Race where queens put on glasses to compete to “read” someone, i.e., insult them the deepest and funniest? Well, queens, the library is open, and we have a winner. As completely unwritten as this line is in Tolkien’s legendarium, Sauron was the king of diabolical double entendres.
Sauron taunted his prisoner Gorlim in The Lay of Leithian by saying he’d reunite him with his wife when what he really meant was that his wife was dead and he was going to kill Gorlim. Poor schmuck. So Sauron suggesting to Celeborn, in one fell swoop, that his wife is not just looking for him but thinking about him in bed hits exactly right. Especially because he’s, well, right.

Of Valar, Valier and Elves
Isildur (Maxim Baldry) meets Elrond in another Rings of Power-defining moment. Isildur and Elrond meet later in the Second Age in The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion, not here. But the scene is powerful because Isildur has been characterised so well as a man haunted by the old Númenor, one he searches for like a man bereft. The immortal Elrond is the old Númenor, his brother the founder of the Valar-blessed island, and here he stands.
Isildur is plagued by an all-too-familiar existential melancholia, the mourning of an irretrievable past. That feels spot on for Isildur, whose immense heroic sacrifices in the legendarium are tragically overshadowed by his later failure to resist the One Ring. Isildur meeting Elrond as his hero here makes it all the sadder how the Ring later induces him to ignore Elrond's counsel to throw it into Mount Doom. The Ring then gets lost in the Anduin, falls to Sméagol, then to Bilbo, then to Frodo. And we all know what happens next—Peter Jackson made sure of it.
The blind Míriel (Cynthia Addai-Robinson) exclaiming in Quenya to the Valar and Valier (female Valar) in disbelief upon meeting Elrond is similarly uncanonical magic. Elf ears, hairless cheeks, and possible forewarning notwithstanding, she's just so certain it's him. It's a beautiful way to say that one can have blind faith, but not lose sight. That's subtlety of just the right register in a story about faith, in contrast to being hit over the head with it by episode 3’s Secret Fire.
The final two episodes of The Rings of Power season 3 premiere on Prime Video on November 25. Catch up on the new characters coming in season 3 and what Jamie Campbell Bower has teased about Celeborn’s past.
