Skip to main content

Take the Black: Reviewing The Rings of Power season 3, episodes 5-6

We're heading to Númenor in this week's episode of Take the Black.
ByDaniel Roman
Robert Aramayo (Elrond) and Maxim Baldry (Isildur) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Robert Aramayo (Elrond) and Maxim Baldry (Isildur) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

It's that time again: another episode of Winter Is Coming's Take the Black podcast is live, bringing you a full hour of chatter about the latest goings on in the realms of fantasy and science fiction. Co-host Marq Nettles and I are going on an adventure this week, to Middle-earth and beyond.

Just like last week's episode, the big thing going on in the fantasy space at the moment is the third season of Prime Video's Lord of the Rings prequel show, The Rings of Power. The four-episode premiere had a lot going for it, but can that momentum keep up through the middle of the season? And now that Marq and I have both had a little more time to sit with the current run of episodes, have our opinions changed? Check out the latest episode below and find out:

The Rings of Power remains consistently inconsistent

Our Rings of Power chat shows have been a little different than when Marq and I deep dive on Westeros. I've been following the series since the beginning; Marq is just diving in on season 3, putting the showrunners' claim that it serves as something of a soft reboot to the test. It ends up being a pretty good gauge for how this show is landing with long-time fans and newcomers alike.

And how is it landing, you may ask? Well, both Marq and I are certainly having fun watching it, and having seen the first two seasons of Rings, I can safely say it is a huge step up from what's come before. But the show's Achilles heel of inconsistently balancing its myriad plotlines continues to be a problem. We're all in for Númenor, and the Elves have a lot going on. The Dwarven love triangle, however, hasn't landed especially well for either of us, and we're both mystified by the fact that Gandalf has appeared in a measly two episodes so far. With the season finale dropping next week, time is running out to pay off all these plotlines in a satisfying way.

All said, we're both still very much on board for the ride, and hoping the season can stick the landing.

Beyond The Rings of Power, we get into some new books we've been reading, highlight another show coming down the pike that we're going to discuss in December, and more. Come and join us!


The Take the Black Podcast is available on Apple Music, Spotify, and YouTube! Please subscribe, download, and rate us there or on your podcast platform of choice if you want to show us some love!

New episodes of Take the Black typically drop on Friday afternoon, but next week is special...because it's a holiday in the U.S.! We'll be taking the week off to gorge ourselves on food and sci-fi television; we'll catch you all in December.

From all of us here at Winter Is Coming, enjoy your Thanksgiving holiday if you celebrate, have a great Thursday if you don't, and keep your eyes on the horizon for more fantasy and sci-fi mayhem as we roll into the cold, final month of the year. Winter is coming, after all, and it brings with it plenty of opportunities to curl up under a blanket and get lost in worlds distant and wondrous. See you next time in Middle-earth, Westeros, and beyond!

Add us as a preferred source on Google