Skip to main content

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3 episode 6 recap & review: Sauron delights in a bit of torture

The Rings of Power season 3 delivers some of its most powerful and most unhinged moments all at once in its sixth episode.
ByDaniel Roman
Charlie Vickers as Sauron in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3.
Charlie Vickers as Sauron in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3. | Image: Ben Rothstein/Prime Video.

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power continues, but now more than ever, the finish line for season 3 is beginning to come into sight. The season's sixth episode is all about things coming to a head, in Sauron's quest to forge the One Ring, in Númenor, and in the Dwarven kingdom of Khazad-dûm. "From Valinor" takes some truly wild swings that are certain to leave fans talking for weeks to come, and most all of them land quite well.

If episode 305 was largely set up, here we get an upping of the stakes along with a few key payoffs. Let's not waste any time, and get right into the recap. FULL SPOILERS beyond.

Charlie Vickers (Sauron) and Tyroe Muhafidin (Theo) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Charlie Vickers (Sauron) and Tyroe Muhafidin (Theo) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

The pull of a Ring of Power

"From Valinor" opens with Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) hiding in the Greenwood, Orcs hot on her trail. That would imply that despite Celeborn's gambit in the previous episode, Sauron remained convinced Galadriel was close. As we see later in the episode, it takes a truly gifted liar to fool the Dark Lord.

Galadriel manages to evade the Orcs and their wargs by using her Ring of Power, Nenya. This is the second use of a Ring of Power we've gotten in this episode block, after she used Nenya to heal Celeborn's hand in the previous episode. This show, and Tolkien's legendarium in general, spend so much time discussing the perils of the Rings and how Sauron twisted them; it's a fascinating counterpoint to actually see them being used in a good way.

However, Galadriel doesn't escape cleanly. A Nazgnagôl approaches, and soon reveals itself to be Theo (Tyroe Muhafidin). He begs her for help, and despite the fact that the young Southlander just killed her friend Arondir (Ismael Cruz Córdova) in cold blood, Galadriel agrees. It's from Theo that she learns Celeborn has been taken to Barad-dûr, where Sauron plans to torture him for any information he may have learned during his time in captivity with the Elven smith Maitalle.

Theo asks Galadriel to help him take off his Ring. And despite her initial reluctance, she does. Theo has had one of the more engaging and unpredictable storylines of the season, and this is yet another example. All signs seemed to point to him becoming the Witch-king of Angmar, Sauron's most feared Nazgûl. Yet at this point, he's still fighting his fate. We'll have to watch and see if he's able to escape it, or if his arc is destined to heap tragedy upon tragedy right to the end.

Jamie Campbell Bower (Celeborn) and Morfydd Clark (Galadriel) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Jamie Campbell Bower (Celeborn) and Morfydd Clark (Galadriel) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

The journey for Galadriel and Theo is filled with catharsis, beauty, and the deep-seated dread of knowing that this hope will be short-lived. They make camp on the same hillside near Lórien where she and Celeborn planned to build their home back in the First Age. Theo is tempted multiple times by his Ring, until he hears Galadriel singing. Props need to be given to Morfydd Clark, who has a gorgeous voice and kills it singing in Elvish. Composer Bear McCreary does amazing work here as always; Galadriel, we can now say, is a canonical alto in The Lord of the Rings on screen, and it fits her like a glove.

Moved by her song, and by her willingness to share her deepest hurts with him that drove her toward vengeance over grieving the love she thought she'd lost, Theo asks Galadriel for the hardest thing he possibly can: to help him destroy his Ring of Power. We fade on this scene with them as the sun sets over Lórien, and it feels like one of the last true calms before the storm hits.

I've generally really enjoyed Theo's storyline this season, and everything about this sequence is well-crafted, from the performances to the cinematography, lighting, locations, music, and costuming. Even the Peter Jackson nods are lighter and more tasteful. Yes, the horse ride recalls Arwen's flight from the Nazgûl in The Fellowship of the Ring, but it's far less of a 1:1 copy than Galadriel, Arondir, and Marnûkh's journey in episode 4. These are the kinds of nods I can get behind.

The main qualm I have with Galadriel and Theo is the time it took them to travel to Mordor. They seemingly made it all the way from the Greenwood to Mordor over the span of a single episode, and that's not even taking into account however long it took Theo to ride from Mordor to the Greenwood in the first place. This episode asks us to suspend our disbelief on travel times, and while fantasy viewers have been largely conditioned to that anyway going back all the way to the later seasons of Game of Thrones, it still would have been nice if The Rings of Power didn't toss it completely out the window here. A small bone to pick, but a bone nonetheless.

Eddie Marsan (Thráin) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Eddie Marsan (Thráin) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

Khazad-dûm under siege from within

We also catch up with the Dwarves in episode 306, which feels welcome after they sat out the previous episode. Tháin (Eddie Marsan) has claimed the crown and throne of Khazad-dûm, tossing his brother Durin (Owain Arthur) into a cavern cell deep below the city. The conniving older brother to Durin IV is now able to turn his full attention to finding the seven Dwarven Rings of Power, and right from the off we see that he's going about it as abrasively as possible. Guards ransack people's houses and merchant stalls. Dwarven stone singers try in vain to glean the location of the Rings with their songs. Thráin stations guards in Disa and Durin's home, threatening their children to make Disa (Sophia Nomvete) use her considerable stone singing abilities to help. It's just a mess, from top to bottom (complimentary).

The highlight is a quiet scene where Thráin and Durin talk about their past in the cell, which slows things down enough to let these two actors lean into the material. Thráin telling Durin that he needs the Rings stood out to me, and makes me wonder what exactly his deal is with Sauron. Was he coerced into this situation? Did the Dark Lord make him promises? We've only got two more episodes to find out answers this season, so The Rings of Power has to pull back the curtain soon.

Despite Disa using her stone singing to do as Thráin asks, she still manages to pull a fast one on her escort. She wasn't singing to find the Rings; she was singing to find Durin's cell. Together they manage to knock out the guards, which is almost comically easy considering Durin was supposed to be in a cell and they just...walked in and stared at a corner long enough for him to knock them out. The rub, however, is that the other Dwarven noblewoman in the party overhears Durin say that the Rings are in their own house just before they run off. Whenever we see the Dwarves again, things are going to get interesting.

Cynthia Addai-Robbinson (Míriel) and Maxim Baldry (Isildur) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Cynthia Addai-Robbinson (Míriel) and Maxim Baldry (Isildur) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

Miracles and mixed messages in Númenor

Interesting is certainly a good word to describe what happens in Númenor this episode as well. After learning that the Faithful are about to fight a full-scale battle with Pharazôn's King's Men, Elrond (Robert Aramayo) goes into full-on negotiator mode, trying to reason with Míriel (Cynthia Addai-Robinson) to find a peaceful path forward. If Elrond is the angel on one shoulder for the queen, the devil on the other is Isildur (Maxim Baldry), who has suffered too much at the hands of Pharazôn's men to lay down his anger.

This push and pull makes for great, natural tension throughout the episode. Isildur speaks up in the most frustrating moments, and for the most part it works really well at preventing things from ever feeling relaxed. This is the moment Míriel's story has been speeding toward, but just like Pharazôn, she has her own internal troubles within her faction to deal with before she can find a way through.

While Elrond tries to talk down the Faithful, High King Gil-galad (Benjamin Walker) does the same with Pharazôn, while Lord Belzagar (Will Keen) fills Isildur's role as the most unhelpful person in the room. Belzagar urges Pharazôn to order their army to attack before the Faithful can strike first, but Gil-galad urges the King of Númenor to give Elrond time to work his magic. Walker is exceptional in this scene, exuding the immortal authority of Gil-galad as he orders Pharazôn's own guards to stop and obey him.

Walker has a few more excellent scenes in this episode, solidifying him as one of the MVPs of the Númenor storyline in "From Valinor." Míriel does indeed send a messenger asking for a parley, validating Gil-galad's belief in Elrond. Gil-galad takes Pharazôn's response to Míriel himself, which is the perfect excuse for him to hold council with the queen before the upcoming parley. Míriel's faith sings on screen when she's opposite the Elves, and never is that more true than during her big moment with Gil-galad, where she rues the fact that she won't be able to see Pharazôn at their meeting because she's blind, and the Elven king gently touches her hand, healing her eyes with his Ring of Power. The choice to cut to black on that moment and flip things into Míriel's perspective as her eyesight returns is an inspired choice, and helps elevate this as one of the most emotionally resonant moments of The Rings of Power season 3.

Trystan Gravelle (Pharazôn) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Trystan Gravelle (Pharazôn) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

Míriel's summit with Pharazôn makes full use of the spectacular sets the production built for Númenor. When the queen rides into the city and up to the tent Pharazôn had erected for their meeting, there's a grandness to the moment, making it clear this is when the future of Númenor may be decided.

After Isildur nearly gets everyone killed with an outburst, Míriel convinces Pharazôn to meet in private. There, she and her cousin level with each other, both admitting that they have problems in their own ranks drawing their attention away from their conflict. One of the fascinating things about this whole Númenor civil war story is that Pharazôn and Míriel don't hate each other; they actually understand each other better than most. It adds an extra dimension that makes this face-to-face meeting extremely compelling, as they two prospective rulers speak bluntly and realistically about how they can resolve the war before it truly starts.

Míriel offers to send her own legions with Pharazôn's to Middle-earth, the better to crush Sauron beneath their might. But Pharazôn doesn't believe that will work...unless the strife on the island is settled. And he has just the idea: a marriage between himself and Míriel.

Lloyd Owen as Elendil in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3.
Lloyd Owen as Elendil in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3. | Image: Ben Rothstein/Prime Video.

While all this is happening, Elendil (Lloyd Owen) and Anárion (Andrew Richardson) wait with their army nearby, ready to charge the King's Men at the first word from Míriel. Elendil offers his own ration to Kemen (Leon Wadham), trying to pick the prisoner's brain for whether Pharazôn would still attack even with his own son captive. Kemen is betting that Pharazôn will; remember, he's still not technically the king's heir, so he's more disposable than he would be otherwise.

This leads to a nice bit of back-and-forth between Elendil and Anárion, with the latter frustrated that his father would give some of their limited food to a man who'd gladly see them all dead. Elendil replies by quoting Elros, and dropping this absolute parental truthbomb on Anárion: "If you are ready to die for the Faithful, my son, then I suggest you start living like one." Elendil continues to remind me so much of Viggo Mortensen's Aragorn in the best way.

Despite Elendil's preaching about patience and following Míriel's lead, the second Isildur shows up with a report of the marriage between the queen and Pharazôn, Elendil takes off on his horse to stop her. The possibility of a romance between Míriel and Elendil is something fans have wondered about since season 2; if there was ever a time to address it, it's going to be in the upcoming final two episodes of season 3.

Charlie Vickers (Sauron) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Charlie Vickers (Sauron) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

Sauron lets loose with Celeborn...and finds the answer he was seeking

The rest of "From Valinor" centers on Sauron (Charlie Vickers), fully embracing his identity as the Dark Lord as he torture Celeborn (Jamie Campbell Bower). This is an important episode for both of these characters, and the actors absolutely knock it out of the park — which is all the more impressive considering some of the truly wild swings this episode took with them.

Sauron begins simply by asking Celeborn questions, hanging him from chains in a cave. When Celeborn gives as good as he gets, they move the torture to a device Celebrimbor (Charles Edwards) invented as a rudimentary printing press. Sauron has found another use for it: squeezing the life out of his victims until they beg him to let them spill all their secrets. And squeezing the life out of someone takes quite a long time when they're an Elf, immortal to all but fatal wounds.

The torture sequence is brutal, with the weight crushing ever lower onto Celeborn as Sauron's Orcs add metal bars smelted from the fires of Mount Doom. It serves the dual purpose of letting Sauron explain why the fires of Mount Doom are as hot as they are, because the worst of mankind's criminals were sent to the volcano for execution during the days of Morgoth. We need to know all this so that when Sauron's ultimate realization that he'll need a fire hot enough to melt Fëanor's hammer hits, we'll know exactly where he's going to do it.

Despite all the torture, Celeborn doesn't break. He spits blood in Sauron's face. It's then we get our first inkling things are about to get weird, when Sauron wipes the blood off with a finger and licks it. "Now we are one. Now we are joined," he murmurs.

The next time we see Celeborn, he's back in his cell, finally given a chance to rest after his ordeals. But lo! Galadriel bursts in to the rescue. If you rolled your eyes when this happened, you aren't alone. But before I could finish scoffing out how convenient and rushed it all felt, The Rings of Power comes in for the gut punch you'll never expect. As Celeborn reveals the secret Sauron's been looking for to Galadriel — that the Rings need gold and silver from Valinor — she kisses him, and the camera pans around to reveal that it's in fact Sauron doing the kissing.

Look, it's impossible to watch this show without knowing all about the fervor on the internet for "Hot Sauron," and the showrunners have made no secret of the fact that there's a messed up love triangle of sorts going on this season between Galadriel, Celeborn, and Sauron. But I did not expect them to actually go for it like this. Kudos to The Rings of Power for having the guts to go there. It gave me shades of Black Jack Randall from Outlander's first season, in terms of what a shocking violation it was to see the woman Celeborn loved turn into the man who was tormenting him. I'm sure there will be a contingent of the fanbase that won't get behind it, but in terms of Sauron messing with his prisoner's mind, it's hard to think of a way he could have cut Celeborn deeper.

The cherry on top of the torture sequence is when Sauron takes up Fëanor's hammer, knowing that it's contains the precious metals from Valinor he needs to create his One Ring. Celebrimbor appears to him again, taunting him about the fact that Fëanor built his hammer in such a way that no fire could possibly melt it. Enough heat does not exist...except in one place: Mount Doom, of course.

This scene calls into question the exact nature of Celebrimbor's ghost. From his appearance in the season 3 premiere, I believed that Celebrimbor was appearing as a figment of Sauron's subconscious. But watching him grow surprised in this scene, while Sauron smirks because he already knew the answer, calls that into question. Could it be that the Dark Lord is actually using his necromancy to commune with Celebrimbor's spirit, perhaps even denying the smith his true rest in the afterlife? I'm not sure The Rings of Power is going to answer this, but from this ending, I'm more curious than ever.

"From Valinor" ends with a long pan out of Barad-dûr, to Mount Doom beyond. We all know what's coming in episode 7: it's time for Sauron to forge the One Ring to rule them all. Next Wednesday can't get here fast enough.

Charlie Vickers (Sauron) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3.
Charlie Vickers (Sauron) in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3. | Courtesy of Prime Video.

Verdict

"From Valinor" is a strong episode of The Rings of Power that expertly balances multiple plotlines while moving them all forward in significant ways. Manipulation is a key theme in this installment, as basically everyone is trying to maneuver people in one way or another, even in storylines where it's completely altruistic like Galadriel and Theo. The evolving situation in Númenor and Sauron's utterly unhinged torture of Celeborn solidify this as a worthy cliffhanger before the two-part finale next week. All roads lead to Mount Doom!

Episode grade: B+

Add us as a preferred source on Google