This interview contains SPOILERS for The Rings of Power season 3 through episode 6, "From Valinor."
Prime Video's epic fantasy series The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power is speeding toward its season 3 climax, and for characters like Theo, there'll be no going back to the way things were before. The young Southlander has been a fixture on the show since its very first episode, but season 3 saw him step to the forefront in a brutal, unexpected way as one of the Dark Lord Sauron's chief Nazgnagôl. In episode 6, he had another shocking turn when he asked Galadriel for help in staving off the darkness, setting up the question of whether there's any road back for Theo as one of the main cliffhangers heading into the season 3 finale.
Few characters on The Rings of Power have had quite as massive of a journey as Theo, played by 20-year-old Australian actor Tyroe Muhafidin. Muhafidin was only 14 when the show started filmed its first season, making him the youngest recurring actor on the cast. It was his first acting role. Theo's arc began with him as a resentful teen, toying with the Southlands' dark history as he watched his mother, Bronwyn (Nazanin Boniadi) fall in love with the Elf Arondir (Ismael Cruz Córdova). After Bronwyn was killed off-screen between seasons 1 and 2, Theo and Arondir grew closer as they traveled with the stranded Númenórean Isildur (Maxim Baldry), until finally, it seemed Theo found peace at the port village of Pelargir.
That peace was short-lived. In season 3, we discover that Pelargir was turned into a hard labor camp, transforming the Númenóreans from saviors into oppressors for those trapped there, like Theo. This drove him to ally with Sauron, who in turn revealed that Theo's father hailed from a noble bloodline that served the original Dark Lord, Morgoth. Theo donned a Ring, becoming a dreaded and powerful Nazgnagôl.
We had the opportunity to speak with Muhafidin over Zoom about Theo's intense journey into darkness, what it was like filming some of his biggest scenes of season 3, his upcoming Netflix thriller Breakers, acting opposite iconic villain actors like Charlie Vickers (Sauron) and The Boys' Antony Starr, and more. Read on to explore our full conversation, edited for clarity and length.

How Tyroe Muhfadin learned of Theo's spiral into darkness
It should come as no surprise that despite acting in The Rings of Power for six years, Muhafidin was largely kept in the dark about where things were heading for Theo. That all changed when it came time to produce season 3.
"It's so funny, I'd been kind of really pushing and like antagonizing [showrunners J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay] to tell me, does Theo get a Ring, all the way up until this season," Muhafidin recalled. "And at the time when they told me, I was still in Australia, this is like way before we started filming, and they kind of sat me down on Zoom and...laid out a lot of my storyline for me. But they also did decide to leave out a few key elements of that storyline. Essentially what they told me was that, you know, Theo would be getting a Ring, and that was kind of that moment of like, okay, here we go. It's time now."
Despite only learning that Theo would be wielding a Ring of Power ahead of production on season 3, Muhafidin already had his suspicions that something bigger was coming down the line for the Southlander. "I always knew this character was building up to something, I just never knew what. And maybe that was the fun part of the character, was kind of guessing what his trajectory was," he said. "But I think this season was really great because I finally got to dive into what he actually was destined to be, and really dive into all those kind of dark emotions and dark feelings that I always slightly played with in the beginning, but I could really go fully fledged this season, which was nice."

Saying goodbye to Arondir
Once Theo turns toward darkness, it isn't long before he causes his first major casualty — and it's one that hits close to home. In the climax of episode 4, as Galadriel's party tries to fight their way out of the Orc prison of Gundabad, Theo comes face-to-face with Arondir, his former father figure and mentor. Despite both Theo and Galadriel's pleas for him to flee, Arondir stands his ground, refusing to abandon Theo to the shadow.
That proves to be his death, when Sauron commands Theo to kill Arondir and the young Nazgnagôl is forced to obey without hesitation. It's by far one of the biggest deaths on the series to date, and for those involved, it was a scene fraught with "so many different waves of emotion."
"It kind of went through so many different motions, that scene," Muhafidin recalled. "Firstly talking to Ismael... we first kind of had a heart-to-heart about it because...it's hard for one to not be in a show anymore, and so, for me it was a big thing of like trying to be there for a mate and kind of help him through it. But you know, I, at the same time, also felt so horrible and so guilty because I'm like, 'Oh, I'm sorry I did this to you bro, like you ain't got this job anymore because of me.'"
"We spoke a lot, and he really let me know that he doesn't think that there was anyone better to do it. And you know, I think storywise and kind of our relationship-wise as well...how close we became over the last seven years, that it really kind of felt like there was only one person who could kill this man, do you know what I mean? I felt like...I earned that. We built our relationship to this point."Tyroe Muhf
Having worked together for so long, Córdova and Muhafidin have had plenty of time to bond on set. But when it came time to actually film Arondir's death, Muhafidin remembers it being a "real slog to get through emotionally, I would say, for everyone involved."
"[Ismael] and I generally have quite a lighthearted relationship, it's kind of brotherly, we like to tease each other a lot, so I think initially I did a lot of teasing of the fact that I was killing him, but when the actual day arrived...all of that fun energy kind of disappeared, you know, and everything became real," he said. "And there was this like sense of coldness and emptiness in the air, and it was really kind of quite hollow and dark, those days shooting."
Despite how draining it was to film Arondir's death scene, it was also important to Muhafidin and the rest of the team on set that it felt like "it was also a celebration of Ismael and a celebration of Arondir, and...how incredible all the work he's put in was, and all the amazing things Arondir has done."

Becoming a Nazgnagôl
While Theo has had an immense emotional journey in season 3, he's also undergone one of the most noticeable physical transformations as well. Muhafidin already put on muscle for Theo to bring out how the character has changed post-time jump, but then, once the Nazgnagôl suit goes on, the boy we've watched grow up on the show truly vanishes into a towering warrior of darkness. It's a testament to Muhafidin's poise as well as the costuming department that they managed to bring this character to a place where he can not only stand toe-to-toe with the likes of prominent heroes like Galadriel and Arondir, but be believably intimidating next to them.
"It's a lot of layers that I probably was wearing, seven or eight layers in that costume, which means that it's, one, it's very heavy, but two, it's very hot," Muhafidin said of his Nazgnagôl attire. "And when we're shooting in Barad-dûr, which is extremely dark and filled with fire everywhere, it's not the easiest conditions to try and shoot in... I like to say that the hardest part of acting is pretending you're not uncomfortable, because 90% of the time you are [in whatever] kind of costume."
"Once you forget about that, it genuinely was crazy," he continued. "Anytime I put those gauntlets on...you can kind of feel the darkness just like pulsing through the veins and you just kind of automatically, as soon as like that costume went on, you know, my shoulders and my back and my chest came out and I felt like I couldn't be defeated, and it is genuinely a confidence that I've never felt before."

Is there any hope for Theo in The Rings of Power?
Following the death of Arondir, Theo's story takes another huge turn in episode 306, when he mets up with Galadriel and asks for her help in taking off the Ring — and then, later, for her aid in destroying it. Yet even then, it's clear the Ring still has a hold over him. As he tells Galadriel after she's removed it from his finger, losing it feels "like one of my limbs was sawed off...and the rest of me's screaming for it to be rejoined."
It all sets up a question: is there any hope that Theo can come back to the light? Muhafidin very much thinks the answer is yes. "I think the fact that he can self-recognize and self-regulate, for one, shows the amount of light that is still in him, and in his soul."
"Theo is very much a product of who his role models are, and who his guidance is," Muhafidin continued. "In a lot of his life, his biggest role model and his biggest guide was his mum, who showed him how to love and be loving... His mum passes away, and his next role model is Arondir, who teaches him to be strong and how to be a warrior and to fight. And then his next role model is Sauron, who teaches him how to kill, how to be dark...how to hurt people. So I think this season is very much that internal conflict of all these different influences of his life, all fighting against each other in his head."
"We see the influences of Sauron fighting against his initial instincts as a person that his mum taught him and raised him to have, and I think those pieces of light that he held and that love that he held...is so valuable because it shows that he's still in there somewhere, and maybe he is salvageable."Tyroe Muhafidin on Theo's redemption

Working with Sauron
While Theo goes through a few notable role models in his run on The Rings of Power, season 3 largely revolves around his relationship with Sauron. It should be no surprise then that Muhafidin singled out one of his scenes with Vickers as his biggest pinch-me moment on set, when it really sank in just how much more prominent his character was going to be in season 3 than the previous two.
"That scene with Charlie Vickers around the fire [in episode 2] was very much that kind of moment, just looking into the eyes of Sauron and hearing the words that he was saying to me...that was the moment that was like, 'Wow, okay, I really am here,'" Muhafidin said. It was then that he realized, "I must be a part of this show pretty significantly because he's a very significant part of it. So if we are in scenes together, they must like me, you know."

Sauron may be a twisted role model for Theo in season 3, but behind the scenes, Vickers was just as much of one to Muhafidin — though thankfully in a much more wholesome way. The actor called it "amazing" to work with Vickers this season.
"Charlie is like an absolute dream," he said. "The first two seasons I really, really wanted to work with him, just in the sense...you know, as a mate, I kind of really looked up to him... From the first season when I was 14, he put an arm around me and really kind of took me under his wing, and we would play PlayStation together in his hotel room and just like hang out like bros, because you know, I didn't really have any friends my own age, and I didn't really have anyone. And so he really...was amazing, in kind of building that reationship."
"And then this season, you know, after already building a relationship with him personally, it made it so easy to then build onto it with our characters," Muhafidin added. "Watching him transform was genuinely one of the most inspiring things to see as an actor, I think. He is kind of everything that I want to work towards to be. He is the most humble, genuine, kindest, caring soul, but then the cameras turn on. It's awful and horrible and evil conniving and manipulative, and it is fantastic to watch."
"I think that was one of those moments where you're working with someone and you're looking at them like, this is an actor and this is who I want to be. And yeah, I have the highest, highest respects for him."Tyroe Muhafidin on Charlie Vickers

From Sauron to Homelander: Acting with master villains
While The Rings of Power is so far Muhafidin's biggest and most notable role, he'll soon be making the leap from Prime Video to Netflix, where he'll star in the psychological thriller series Breakers, about two best friends from the U.S. who go backpacking in Australia, where they fall in with a surfing community led by an unnervingly charismatic man named Brando — who is played by none other than Antony Starr, the actor behind Homelander on The Boys. Yes, Muhafidin is trading in one master villain actor for another; are we sensing a trend?
"I'm kind of collecting the villain Infinity Stones now. Vecna, Sauron, and Homelander, it's crazy," he joked.
Breakers represented a huge change for Muhafidin, because it was the first time he'd been able to act in his home country of Australia. "We shot just two hours south of where I grew up, which was kind of the craziest experience because my whole experience as an actor is, you know, basically Rings, which means traveling very far distances to work and being away from home for a very, very long time," Muhafidin explained. "My whole experience of being an actor and working is being homesick. And so this was the first job that I did where I didn't feel homesick at all because I was home, which was really, really incredible. I could just do my job and feel like I was working, which was nice."
As for working with Starr, an actor known for playing one of the most rivetingly psychotic villains on modern television, Muhafidin clearly took notes. He said that Starr is "very similar to Charlie, in that he will be the most outgoing guy and super chill, but as soon as the camera rolls he can turn it on."
"I think Antony specifically has this really incredible knack for moving small bits of his face to change the entire expression," he continued. "I don't want to get too much into spoiler territory, but I think he plays Brando so well in the sense of showing just enough to be believable, but knowing that there's more going on that you don't know and you want to find out... And watching that in real life right in front of me was very, very inspiring, but also very scary."
Filming Galadriel's song in The Rings of Power episode 306
Jumping back to The Rings of Power, we couldn't let Muhafidin go without asking him about filming perhaps the most beautiful scene of the season that he was involved in: the moment in episode 6 where Theo is frantically searching for his Ring in Galadriel's bag, only to pause when he hears the Elf singing behind him as she gazes out over the forest of Lórien.
"For some reason in reading the script, I lost the fact that [Morfydd Clark] would sing in the scene. And so when we were doing the rehearsal, people kept, you know, talking to Miv and asking her like, do you wanna sing or we can play a guide track," he recalled. "I think she opted for the guide track, the soundtrack. But I remember them saying that and me being so confused...but then, we actually talked through the scene and walked it through and I kind of realized the vibe of what's going on."
"I think, Miv had recorded like a track before filming, and so anytime that she was doing her thing, when it would get to that point in the scene where I hear her sing, they would just play it over a speaker," he added.
Before this point, Galadriel had never sung in The Rings of Power. But there's a long precident for Elvish singing in Tolkien's legendarium, which makes this scene feel incredibly faithful to the spirit of the master fantasist's work.
"There's something about the Elven language and also Morfydd's voice in the sense that it's so elegant and gracious and filled with so much love, and playing that in the moment to just feel relaxed automatically became so [genuine], because it really was very, very soothing to listen to," Muhafidin said. "I think Morfydd is incredibly talented and a great, great soul."
Clark isn't the only one with musical talents, either. When he's not acting, Muhafidin self-produces his own hip hop and indie music, which you can check out on Spotify and all the other large music platforms.

The Rings of Power season 3 finale awaits
It's been quite a journey for Theo and Tyroe Muhafidin on The Rings of Power, but some of the most breathtaking material may be yet to come. On November 24, Prime Video will premiere the seventh and eighth episodes of the season, bringing Sauron, the Elves, the Númenóreans, and wildcard characters like Theo and the Wizard Gandalf together on a massive collision course. Sauron will forge the One Ring — and we'll find out whether Theo's plea to Galadriel to help him destroy his own bears fruit. It promises to be an epic sendoff for this chapter of The Lord of the Rings on screen.
"Some things really start happening in episode eight, and you're gonna have to watch it to find out," Muhafidin teased.
Only a few more days, and we'll discover what exactly he means — and whether Theo is doomed to darkness, or can claw his way back to the light.
The two episode finale for The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power premieres November 24 at 9:00 p.m. ET / 6:00 p.m. PT on Prime Video. We'll be covering the finale extensively, so check back for more!
